On Top of It #12: No One Cares What You Write

On Top of It #12 by Lisa Martens

No One Cares What You Write

As an MFA student, a writer, and an occasional blogger, I’ve met a lot of other aspiring writers. Most are beaming with hope, stewing with bitterness, and take pride in not having their shit together. And a good deal of them live in fear of the Internet, of having their precious words stolen from their hard drives, or of someone they fucked reading their stories and piecing it all together.

I have an encouraging message to all of you: No One Cares What You Write.

Let me explain. If you’re reluctant to write something because your ex who was a fantastic lover might see it, don’t worry. He probably won’t. Go ahead and describe his dick at length (well, you should probably change his name or some minor details).

Fact is: the only people who have ever griped to me about stuff I’ve written were people I didn’t even write about. They only thought I was writing about them. . . the funniest part has been that everyone who has ever assumed I was writing about them has been wrong, and the fantastic lovers, well, they’re probably too busy having sex to care. Sadly.

So write what you want . . . within reason. Don’t send a bunch of threatening letters and pretend it’s freedom of speech, and then blame me when you get arrested. This post isn’t for people hiding behind the mask of the Internet. This post is for people who have great ideas, ideas inspired by their real-life interactions . . . but who are too afraid to write about them for fear that someone they know will see it and make some connections.

Maybe a few people will. But if someone is spending that much time picking apart your writing and figuring out your psyche, they’re probably lacking in their own lives, and you don’t have to care about their opinion. It won’t be someone you’re actually afraid of. It’ll be the kind of person who will text you at length but never make IRL plans with you.

It won’t be that gorgeous slab of man meat you messaged three years ago whose Facebook profile you occasionally stalk. You know, the one whose security settings you circumvented so you could see all his photos. You’ll want him to message you and ask if that quasi-erotic fanfiction you wrote was about him, but he won’t. Because he’s probably climbing some mountain in Alaska.

Another thing—If someone is going to steal your book idea, they will only do it when the book is finished. No one is going to try to steal your actual ideas and try to create a 150,000-word novel and figure out all the characters and plot holes you haven’t ironed out. If anything, if they’ve hacked into your computer and gone that far, they’re probably going to just steal your identity and buy stuff.

So if you want to protect your credit card info, hide it in a folder labeled “novel ideas.” No one will ever, ever steal it.

_______

Lisa Martens

Lisa Martens (Episode 22) currently lives in Harlem. In her past 10 years in New York, she has lived in a garage on Long Island, a living room in Hell’s Kitchen, the architecture building of CCNY, and on the couch of a startup. She grew up in New York, Costa Rica and Texas, and she’s still not sure which of these is home. She completed her MFA in Creative Writing from CCNY. Her thesis, What Grows in Heavy Rain, is available on Amazon. Check out her website here. Follow her on Instagram here.



11 responses to “On Top of It #12: No One Cares What You Write”

  1. Parveen Sabharwal Avatar
    Parveen Sabharwal

    Very true Lisa. If you started writing any stuff try it with your original ideas which only u can access. So why to worry. Write freely openly and full of information that arouses anxiety. Love it. Have fun

  2. Hi there. Interesting post. I am concerned about one person who I gave a draft of my novel to read and provide feedback. Right after that he broke up with one of my friends who I’m close with, never responded to my messages, never gave me any feedback, and never actually talked to me again. I moved shortly after that. And the person is an aspiring artistic type with actual criminal past (the details were coming out after that breakup). Granted, it was only 2nd draft, but it is fixable. What are my odds being screwed here? Can that person copyright it and maybe sell it? Or wait until I’m done and sue me?

  3. On another point, I have a different draft that I thought will never see the light of the day, because it is an autobiographical, on subjects if rape and sexual harassment in the workplace (it’s Anita Hill meets Mechelle Vinson meets … Lolita (?) story, really sad stuff) and I was never into making it public. I don’t want the story to be associated with me. I moved on. Life is good. But recently I went back, and the writing is so inspired (at least to me), and plus I think someone in similar situations might find it useful. Plus, my sister works in the same place, but her situation is safe. However, I’m afraid she may experience experience retaliation retaliation. What do you think? Turning it into fiction? Will it lose gravity? Write uneder a pen name? (Sorry for typos if any, typing from my phone and I can see only one line at a time in the comment box).

    1. Hi Ellie!

      Protecting a loved one is very different than restricting what you write based on fear, which was what I was going for here. With the Internet, people have reached new levels of paranoia, which can hinder productivity. If you’re so worried about protecting your idea, then you may never work on it or show your hard work to the world 😦

      That is unfortunate that someone took your manuscript and bailed with it. While it may be unlikely that someone will go through the effort to sell a manuscript you wrote, if they have the whole thing, that is certainly easier. There’s still the process of reading it, editing it, and actually getting it published, which is a huge deterrent, but it’s possible. (Most crooks would rather have something they can steal a bit faster, and sell easier.) I would recommend Copyrighting your stuff ASAP and visiting this page:

      http://www.pw.org/content/copyright?cmnt_all=1

      As for the autobiographical piece, it may help to fictionalize it. I do a lot of that in my own writing. My recent book has elements of truth, but enough is changed . . . something happening in real life obviously gives inspiration and an extra punch. But I think the other challenge is how to keep the same punch while writing fiction. What about that piece is so powerful? Does the voice change? The sentence structure? Flip the genders, how does it change? I’m a big believer that we do not have to be limited by our experiences when we write.

      I hope this helps 😀 write on!

      1. Thanks for taking time on this response. I actually wasn’t paranoid too much until I saw your post, just got me thinking. So thanks.

  4. The road to publication is especially long and difficult, so the odds of someone successfully plagiarizing your work all the way to the marketplace are incredibly tiny, as in a miracle has occurred. However, it is a good policy to show your work only to people you trust to keep it in confidence, writers who have demonstrated significant pride in their own work.

    As for how to deal with nonfiction that may have real-life consequences to yourself and your family, there are the solutions you have indeed suggested. David Sedaris has a policy that his family can veto his work if they think he has abused their privacy in ways they don’t like. Your sister’s opinion is probably relevant to your project. If you say the writing feels inspired, then perhaps a fictionalized version will work. You could also change the names of the people and companies involved if you stay with nonfiction, to protect the innocent. Writing under a pen name seems like a poor choice, as it interferes with your ability to build a public image as an author, unless you stick with that pen name–and in the internet age, the secret of a pen name isn’t likely to stay a secret to anyone who really wants to know. Unless this harassment occurred recently (and the Anita Hill reference makes me think not), then perhaps fiction is the best option.

    1. I mentioned Anita Hill as a cultural benchmark. Re Sedaris’ policy, wow, I did not know. It is a noble one. Particularly when as writers, sometimes we want to unleash hell loose, when in pain and with a notepad handy.

  5. Hi Ellie!

    Protecting a loved one is very different than restricting what you write based on fear, which was what I was going for here. With the Internet, people have reached new levels of paranoia, which can hinder productivity. If you’re so worried about protecting your idea, then you may never work on it or show your hard work to the world 😦

    That is unfortunate that someone took your manuscript and bailed with it. While it may be unlikely that someone will go through the effort to sell a manuscript you wrote, if they have the whole thing, that is certainly easier. There’s still the process of reading it, editing it, and actually getting it published, which is a huge deterrent, but it’s possible. (Most crooks would rather have something they can steal a bit faster, and sell easier.) I would recommend Copyrighting your stuff ASAP and visiting this page:

    http://www.pw.org/content/copyright?cmnt_all=1

    As for the autobiographical piece, it may help to fictionalize it. I do a lot of that in my own writing. My recent book has elements of truth, but enough is changed . . . something happening in real life obviously gives inspiration and an extra punch. But I think the other challenge is how to keep the same punch while writing fiction. What about that piece is so powerful? Does the voice change? The sentence structure? Flip the genders, how does it change? I’m a big believer that we do not have to be limited by our experiences when we write.

    I hope this helps 😀 write on!

  6. I agree with John about the pen name. I tried pen names for a long time, and it just divided the people who liked my work under different names 😦

    1. Something I will consider. Thank you for the advice.

  7. I appreciate the honesty of this post. I was personally terrified of posting anything original online because of people stealing my ideas. But you brought up a good point of if they’re lazy enough to steal, they’re going to wait for the finished product. Maybe it’s because I forget that the only one living in my head is me (at least what I’m aware of lol), and just because I post a free write or sketch doesn’t mean the viewer instantaneously knows everything about what there is to know. Paranoia is a bitch.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

About

The Drunken Odyssey is a forum to discuss all aspects of the writing process, in a variety of genres, in order to foster a greater community among writers.

Newsletter

%d bloggers like this: